The results are in over at Leiter Reports...over 900 people voted :
1. Plato (Condorcet winner: wins contests with all other choices) |
2. Aristotle loses to Plato by 367–364 |
3. Kant loses to Plato by 411–328, loses to Aristotle by 454–295 |
4. Hume loses to Plato by 534–166, loses to Kant by 533–176 |
5. Descartes loses to Plato by 597–117, loses to Hume by 356–269 |
6. Socrates loses to Plato by 548–101, loses to Descartes by 327–270 |
7. Wittgenstein loses to Plato by 610–85, loses to Socrates by 385–193 |
8. Locke loses to Plato by 659–29, loses to Wittgenstein by 311–239 |
9. Frege loses to Plato by 611–86, loses to Locke by 279–256 |
10. Aquinas loses to Plato by 642–57, loses to Frege by 289–284 |
11. Hegel loses to Plato by 615–82, loses to Aquinas by 288–285 |
12. Leibniz loses to Plato by 650–36, loses to Hegel by 281–266 |
13. Spinoza loses to Plato by 653–49, loses to Leibniz by 281–207 |
14. Mill loses to Plato by 645–39, loses to Spinoza by 272–247 |
15. Hobbes loses to Plato by 647–47, loses to Spinoza by 269–245 |
16. Augustine loses to Plato by 663–46, loses to Mill by 296–247 |
17. Marx loses to Plato by 653–52, loses to Augustine by 305–248 |
18. Nietzsche loses to Plato by 691–63, loses to Marx by 327–269 |
19. Kierkegaard loses to Plato by 622–106, loses to Nietzsche by 330–256 |
20. Rousseau loses to Plato by 638–41, loses to Kierkegaard by 280–209 |
The usual suspects round out the the top five, but Frege and Wittgenstein in the top ten?!